[Archivist's note: Mirrored from John Cowan's site, at http://home.ccil.org/~cowan/essential.html.
Essentialist Explanations
12th edition
This page comprises a list of 876
"essentialist explanations" of the
form "Language X is essentially language Y under conditions Z".
I have edited some entries for uniformity, clarity, or good English.
The entries are grouped for convenience rather than correctness.
In particular, fictional languages belonging to actual language families
are grouped with their natural language relatives.
New contributions are
solicited,
especially for American and African languages. No flames, please.
"[We] do but jest, poison in jest, no offence in the world." --Hamlet
Index
- English (53 entries)
- English (Specific Varieties) (63 entries)
- North Germanic (41 entries)
- West Germanic (High) (29 entries)
- West Germanic (Low) (34 entries)
- Spanish (26 entries)
- Austronesian (14 entries)
- Latin and Italian (31 entries)
- French (29 entries)
- Portuguese (19 entries)
- Other Romance (40 entries)
- Slavic (43 entries)
- Celtic (24 entries)
- Greek (11 entries)
- Baltic, Indo-Iranian, Dravidian (34 entries)
- Uralic (29 entries)
- Afroasiatic (44 entries)
- Afroasiatic, Ancient (20 entries)
- Sino-Tibetan, Japanese, Korean, Vietnamese (43 entries)
- Altaic (30 entries)
- Miscellaneous (38 entries)
- Esperanto (15 entries)
- Other International Auxiliary Languages (16 entries)
- Other Artificial Languages (A-M) (54 entries)
- Other Artificial Languages (N-Z) (43 entries)
- Tolkien Languages (13 entries)
- Animal Languages (5 entries)
- Writing Systems (28 entries)
- Basque (7 entries)
- English
- English is essentially bad Dutch with outrageously
pronounced French and Latin vocabulary.
- --Eugene Holman
- English is essentially Norse as spoken by a gang of French thugs.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- English is essentially a bizarre dialect of Chinese, pronounced
entirely in the first tone.
- --John Cowan
- English is essentially any other language spoken with a very hot potato
in one's mouth.
- --Ivan Derzhanski (based on Alain LaBonté on Swiss French)
- English is essentially the language you speak without
moving your mouth.
- --Marianne Cowan
- English is essentially a language that uses vowels no other language would
accept.
- --Luís Henrique
- English is essentially degenerate Welsh steeped in Latin, Dutch and
Franco-Scandinavian Norman.
- --Mike Taylor
- English is essentially German spoken in the mouth rather than the throat.
- --jmallett
- English is essentially Low German plus even lower French minus any sense
of culture.
- --Danny Weir
- English is essentially Anglo-Saxon with all the cool bits taken out.
- --Thomas Leigh
- English is essentially a dialect of French.
- --Alain LaBonté
- ...spoken by Germanic barbarians.
- --Fragano Ledgister
- English is what you get from Normans trying to pick up Saxon girls.
- --Bryan Maloney
- Written English is essentially a variety of Old French
invented by somebody who spoke only Saxon and read only Latin.
- --Basilius
- English is essentially an imprecise dialect of Java, without the
object orientation.
- --Julian Morrison
- English is essentially a language that no one speaks in France.
- --Dan Seriff
- English is essentially French converted to 7-bit ASCII.
- --Christophe Pierret [for Alain LaBonté]
- English is essentially a whore.
- --Lars Hendrik Mathiesen
- English is essentially a French menu stuttered by a fish-and-chips dealer.
- --Kala Tunu
- English is essentially the Borg.
- --Muke Tever
- Men efter all Englisk äre basiklig Svensk förpoisonat of Frensk
(ellor skould dat be Danisk?).
- --Jonathan Knibb
- English is essentially Dutch but it doesn't want to admit it.
- --Danny Wier
- English is essentially a West Germanic language that's trying very hard to look
like a Romance one.
- --Andreas Johansson
- English is essentially language's equivalent to a transvestite.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Modern English read phonetically is essentially
Middle English as no Middle Englishman would have
spoken it.
- --Jake X
- According to generative linguists, all languages are essentially English.
- --Arnt Richard Johansen
- English is essentially the devil's attempt to reverse the curse of Babel
by making a world language from the most difficult language in the world.
- --qaya
- English is essentially Pictish that was attacked out of nowhere
by Angles cohabiting with Teutons who were done in by a drunk bunch
of Vikings masquerading as Frenchmen who insisted they spoke
Latin and Greek but lacked the Arabic in which to convey that.
- --Bill Hammel
- English is essentially Plattdeutsch as spoken by a Frisian pretending to be
French.
- --Andreas Johansson
- English is essentially a stripped-down Germanic lang with
Baroque-style Norman French ornamentation glued on at
odd angles.
- --Adam Walker
- English is essentially a language that doesn't care where syllable
boundaries are.
- --Peter Bleackley
- Inglish iz issenshali a langwidje dhat, wen rittun fonetkli, iz ilejibul tu
netiv spikerz.
- --Peter Bleackley
- English is essentially the language of people who think that everybody else
speaks their language. French is essentially the language of people who
think that everybody else should speak theirs.
- --Peter Bleackley
- English is essentially bad Frisian, old French, Latin, and Greek, with a grammar
that pretends to be like Latin but is really like Chinese or very dumbed-down
Germanic (depending on how you look at it).
- --Trebor Jung
- English is essentially all exceptions and no rules.
- --Jonathan Bettencourt
- English is essentially the works of Joyce with the hard bits taken out.
- --Jon Hanna
- In English, all foreign languages are essentially French.
- --Tristan Mc Leay
- English is essentially Hindi (cot, jungle, shampoo), with a heck of a
lot of loanwords from Anglo-Saxon, French, and Latin.
- --Sean B. Palmer
- English is essentially a Germanic language that
has eaten far too many French dishes for its own good.
- --John Cowan
- English is a structurally Semiticized, lexically Romanized German
dialect.
- --Theo Venneman
- English is essentially the noise made by people who don't believe you
can use language but want your stuff handed over politely.
- --John M. Ford
- English is essentially what happens when you can't decide whether the
Greeks or the Romans had the better civilization, so you ask everybody
they ever beat up on to sort it out.
- --John M. Ford
- English is essentially a language in which up has forty-seven dictionary
definitions, but antidisestablishmentarianism is considered a "hard word."
- --John M. Ford
- English is essentially a text parser's way of getting faster processors
built.
- --John M. Ford
- English is essentially the inevitable result of repressing the gender
of nouns.
- --John M. Ford
- English is essentially ideographic, but it's sneaky about it.
- --John M. Ford
- English was essentially created to be the language of international air
traffic control, but it got bored waiting.
- --John M. Ford
- English is essentially the "universal Martian" used for interplanetary
ditching instructions.
- --John M. Ford
- English is essentially a tale told by an extremely clever and inventive
idiot.
- --John M. Ford
- English is a marriage between German and French.
- --Brian
- English is essentially l33t with the numbers replaced by letters.
- --Shanth
- English is essentially a half dozen other languages locked in a small
room. They fight.
- --M. Kehrt
- English is partly dysfunctional Scandinavian.
- --gooeyfruitbat
- English (Specific Varieties)
- Cockney is essentially English while haggling over prices.
- --Mike Taylor
- Pig Latin is essentially eulological English as spoken by Latin
professors with Tourette's syndrome.
- --ilvi
- Basic English is essentially Rapping, but censored and without the beat.
- --Jay Bowks
- Australian is essentially a dialect of English as spoken by hungry
Europeans pursuing a kangaroo dinner.
- --ilvi
- Australian English is essentially Cockney without the refinement.
- --Öjevind Lång
- American English is essentially English after having been wiped
off with a dirty sponge.
- --J.R.R. Tolkien
- American English is essentially a tool to keep a person from ever
being able to speak another language.
- --jmallett
- American English is essentially British English without the redundancies,
including the monarchy.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Today's British English is what today's American English would have become
if Americans hadn't had any fun either.
- --Glen Perkins
- American English is essentially your Queen's English as bastardized by
colonists, or is it as colonized by bastards?
- --ilvi
- American English is essentially British English without the funny accent.
[Or is that Canadian English?]
- --Aleks Dubh
- American English is essentially Irish English as spoken by
non-native speakers.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- The Queen's English is essentially Modern Anglo-Saxon as passed on by
generation after generation of stiff necked Norman nobles with their noses
in the air.
- --ilvi
- Texan English is essentially Spanish as spoken by drunken American rebels.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Yankee is essentially 18th Century English as altered by the impure
thoughts of Puritans with cabin fever.
- --Jay Bowks
- Jamaican is essentially an African dialect with enough mispronounced English
to be able to buy ganja and sing reggae.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Scots is essentially English, only funnier.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Scots is essentially English as spoken by Robert Burns.
- --Zoe Mulford
- Scots is essentially English spoken as Dutch by a Dane.
- --Mark Odegard
- South Philadelphian is essentially Italian with the final syllables dropped
off.
- --Zoe Mulford
- Southern US English is essentially English without monophthongs.
- --Danny Weir
- Yo! Ebonics is essentially Welfarese processed through a grant-seeking
processor akin to a guitarist's distortion box in the hands of the
psychotropic educrats, homies.
- --laser
- Ebonics essentially is the speech of hoods in the 'hood.
- --laser
- King James English is essentially the language that many Americans
think Jesus spoke. "If English was good enough for Jesus, it's good
enough for me!"
- --Dan Seriff
- Psycho-babble is essentially Minbari spoken by seekers of tax-funded grants,
power-hungry psycho-totalitarians, counsellors or other unemployables while
wearing a too-tight tiara.
- --laser
- Galach is essentially Anglo-Slavic run through Grimm's Law and baked on the
desert of Arrakis until well-dune.
- --laser
- Governmentese is essentially a branch of spoken and written English designed
to say nothing with as many words as possible hoping that the nothing is
lost in the translation.
- --laser
- Old English is essentially mispronounced Modern English spoken while
wearing armor and carrying a roundshield and sword.
- --Dan Seriff
- Middele English is essencially Moderne Lowe Duchish with a heevy Scottisshe
broog yspoken and with ful many fetise Frensshe loon-wordes that been ful
quayntly and straungely ywritten.
- --Amittai Aviram
- New York City Syrian Jewish English is essentially Arabic curses and bad
Ebonics spoken with a Brooklyn accent.
- --Steg Belsky
- Yeshivish is essentially English spoken by people who think they're
speaking Yiddish.
- --Steg Belsky
- 1337Speak is essentially what happens when an AOLer's keyboard breaks.
- --Andy Fox
- American English essentially is not English and is not American either.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Southern US English is essentially Irish English spoken through moonshine and
whiskey instead of stout and ale.
- --Andrew Johnson
- New York English is essentially New England English with a bagel in one's throat
and being mugged.
- --Andrew Johnson
- Liverpool English is Irish English spoken by Irishmen and Welshmen trying to
bash England.
- --Andrew Johnson
- Birmingham English is what the world would sound like if they also snorted coke
laced with ants and drank gasoline every night for 30 years like Ozzy Osbourne.
- --Andrew Johnson
- Midwestern US English is essentially New England English with their sinuses
filled with ice.
- --Andrew Johnson
- American English is essentially the language that everyone
understands if you speak it loudly and slowly enough.
- --Michael Alexander (via Daniel E. Huston)
- Broken English is the language of international trade.
- --John Naisbitt (via Daniel E. Huston)
- Ebonics be Shakespeare playin' da urbon Oak-lan' (Calie-forn-ah) bluz,
homie.
- --Hanuman Zhang
- American is essentially achieved by simplifying and complexifying English
at once.
- --Greg Johnston
- Shetlandic is essentially English taught by Lowlanders to Norwegians.
- --Alexander Ellis
- Newyorkese is English with a Dutch accent and a grudge.
- --Javier Candeira
- American English is essentially an Irish tongue in a Dutch mouth.
- --John Cowan
- New Zealand English is essentially the English somebody forgot to take
it out of their back pocket before putting their jeans through the laundry.
- --Hamish Ritchie
- Lancashire is essentially English spoken properly.
- --Liv Bliss
- Ebonics is basically Manding-Congo/Manding Cushi African languages with English
words, ancient Egyptian parents and polyrhythmic presentation.
- --Paul Barton
- Gullah-Geechee is basically the remnants of the ancient Egyptian syntax found in
Kru, Manding and Serer brought by the Africans to the Sea Islands/Georgia
region and spoken with 'chopped' English words to replace the lost African
ones.
- --Paul Barton
- Jamaican/Caribbean English is basically a combination of Yoruba, Tiv, Manding,
Kongo placed in a saladbowl, mixed and fused and spoken with English words with
a juju music, reggae and calypso rhythm.
- --Paul Barton
- Southern 'white' English is basically the Ebonics English created by Blacks and
used by former speakers of Gaelic, Welsh, English jailbird descent, French
Huguenot descent and other 'poor white' ancestry Southerners who worked on
Southern plantations as 'indentured laborers' alongside African slaves.
- --Paul Barton
- Indian English is essentially late Victorian bureaucratese as spoken by
Peter Sellers.
- --Tommy Tyrberg
- If you wake a Britisher up at five in the morning, he'll sound like a human
being.
- --Brian
- American is essentially British with decent cooking.
- --libcat
- American English is essentially what the English would be speaking
had they kept up their English lessons.
- --Alan Kellogg
- San Diegan is essentially Iowan as spoken by people living in a
geographically interesting location.
- --Alan Kellogg
- Surfer Speak is essentially Iowan as spoken by people who are
perpetually stoned.
- --Alan Kellogg
- American grammar is essentially not essential
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- American is essentially nothing to write home about.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- American English is essentially the "haiku" version of British English
minus the class.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Geordies are essentially Scots speaking English with a Norwegian
accent.
- --Daniel Carrera
- Canadian English is essentially Mid-West American English with
a lot of eh's.
- --contrariandoer
- Essentially, Texan is fake Spanish endings tacked onto every other word,
with occasional bursts of enough German to confuse people.
- --Bob Thornton
- North Germanic
- Norwegian is essentially Danish spoken with a Swedish accent.
- --Eugene Holman (and many others)
- Danish is essentially Norwegian spoken with a sore throat.
- --Kaare Albert Lie
- Danish is essentially Norwegian (or Swedish) spoken while eating
a hot potato.
- --Eugene Holman/Benct Philip Jonsson
- Danish is essentially Swedish spoken while eating porridge.
- --Peter Landgren
- Danish is essentially Swedish while swallowing yogurt.
- --Mike Taylor
- Norwegian is essentially Swedish spoken by eunuchs with false teeth.
- --Peter Landgren
- Swedish is essentially Norwegian spoken by Finns.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Swedish is what happened when a Nordic-speaking people got angry at all the
other Nordic-speaking peoples and
decided to deliberately alter their language to make it look more German.
- --Peter Ravn Rassmussen
- Swedish essentially is a very well camouflaged dialect of Chinese.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Danish is essentially Swedish run backwards at half speed.
- --Tommy Tyrberg
- Danish is essentially Swedish after running over all consonants
that didn't get out of the way fast enough.
- --Tommy Tyrberg
- Swedish is essentially Norwegian spoken while trying to maintain a stiff upper lip.
- --Sten E. Moe
- Danish is essentially Norwegian spoken without a tongue.
- --Sten E. Moe
- Danish is essentially Swedish with the ends of syllables mangled.
- --Lars Mathiesen
- Conversely, Swedish is essentially Danish with the onsets of
syllables mangled.
- --Lars Mathiesen
- Swedish is essentially perfected Danish.
- --Aleks Dubh
- A Gothenburg accent is essentially Swedish with all vowels reduced
to "ö".
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Norse is essentially Gothic as spoken by seasick vikings.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- New Norwegian (Nynorsk) is essentially the speech of Norwegian peasants as
mutilated by a schoolteacher with a poor understanding of Icelandic.
- --Halldór Laxness, via Benct Philip Jonsson
- Danish is essentially Swedish minus articulation.
- --Andreas Johannson
- Danish is essentially [@::::::::::::::::].
- --Andreas Johannson
- Danish is essentially Swedish with a sense of humor.
- --Anders Engwall
- Swedish, Norwegian and Danish are actually the same language.
It's just that the Norwegians can't spell it, and the Danes can't pronounce it.
- --Chlewey
- Faroese is essentially bad Icelandic.
- --Eugene Holman
- Icelandic is essentially bad Old Norse.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Danish is essentially Norwegian, only you drop out all the consonants, skip all
the vowels and then mispronounce the rest.
- --David Oftedal
- Nynorsk (or Redneck, as I call it) is essentially Swedish with a bad accent.
- --David Oftedal
- Swedish is essentially the language of Inscrutable Nordics who decided
to make their language even more inscrutable than before.
- --John Cowan
- Swedo-Norwegian is essentially a dialect continuum, divided vertically
in writing but horizontally in speech.
- --John Cowan
- Icelandic is essentially Norwegian spoken with an American accent.
- --James Worlton
- Swedish is essentially the strangest dialect of Dutch I ever heard.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- Swedish is essentially Spanish with the verbs conjugated backwards.
- --Mark J. Reed
- Swedish is essentially Norwegian plus vowels with tremas.
- --Trebor Jung
- Hungarian is essentially Norwegian spelled backwards, with a lot of ö's.
- --Nils Wærstad
- Swedish is essentially English spoken backwards.
- --Dave Yarwood
- My ex brother-in-law, who is essentially an ass, once told me that Danish is
essentially a "throw-up" language since you feel like you're retching when you
pronounce it. That's essentially his opinion.
- --Sally Caves
- Icelandic is essentially Björk for those who don't know where
Iceland even is.
- --Sally Caves
- Gøtudanskt is essentially Danish spoken the way it is spelled.
- --Philip Newton
- Bokmål is essentially Danish with Swedish phonemes and hippie
intonation.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Norwegian is essentially Japanese as spoken by Germans.
- --The Multilingual Kitten
- To a western Norwegian, East Norwegian is essentially Danish.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- West Germanic (High)
- German is essentially a philosophical cough.
- --Luís Henrique
- German is essentially a language developed by a group of Teutons
who gathered in the forest one day to come up with a language that their
enemies would have no chance of grasping.
- --Jeff Lowery
- German is essentially a guttural dialect of French with more Fs and AUs.
- --jmallett
- Germann ist eßentially Dutsch and Englisch with a few Tschanges.
- --Danny Wier
- Germänn ist eßëntiälly Ënglisch mit ein few
Tschängen und das käpitäal Lëtteren und Lötten
von Dötten.
- --Nik Taylor
- German is essentially a language that had a lot of future up until
about 60 years ago.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Yiddish is essentially bad German mixed with worse Hebrew
and execrable Russian.
- --John Cowan
- Yiddish is essentially a Slavic language where most of the
words just happen to be German.
- --John Cowan
- Conversely, German is essentially a parody of Yiddish.
- --Anonymous, via Jörg Rhiemeier
- Standard German is essentially southern grammar and lexis with
northern phonology.
- --John Cowan
- Bavarian and Austrian are essentially Real German spoken with
a mouth full of spaetzle.
- -- David Bell
- German is essentially a form of assembly language consisting entirely of
far calls heavily accented with throaty guttural sounds.
- --ilvi
- Transylvanian Saxon (Saksesh) is essentially a Luxembourg Yiddish
spoken by old-German Protestants with a Romanian-Hungarian accent.
- --Alfred W. Tüting (.aulun.)
- Proto-Germanic was essentially Proto-Latin spoken with a Proto-Basque
accent.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- German is essentially English as
spoken by a drunken, slurring nuclear-plant technician
desperately trying, and failing, to get a date by
expounding on "The Sorrows of Young Werther" and, then,
logically enough, committing suicide.
- --Thomas Wier
- German essentially Gothic with Latin syntax is.
- --John Hudson
- Yiddish is essentially the modern descendant of a koine of Middle
High German dialects, mixed with Slavic and Hebrew.
- --John Cowan
- Austrian German is essentially Berliner German without all the spitting.
- --Bill Hammel
- Yiddish is essentially the Ebonics of German.
- --submanifold
- German is essentially English spoken with a head cold.
- --Orson Scott Card
- The -le of Schwäbisch clearly demonstrates how it
is essentially Swiss German ashamed of itself.
- --Christian Thalmann
- Essentially is German a verb-second language.
- --Sally Caves
- It is essential, that You the german Syntax and Punctuation right get must.
- --Sally Caves
- German is essentially Yiddish without the Hebrew.
- --Tom Arnold
- Yiddish and Romanian are aberrant dialects of German and Italian with some
Slavic modifications.
- --Brian
- Swiss German is essentially Standard German spoken with laryngitis.
- --Dreas
- German is essentially bastardized Yiddish.
- --Zackary Sholem Berger
- German is essentially Dutch with a gay lisp
- --Heinz Hummer
- Swiss German is essentially German spoken while eating crunchy crackers.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- West Germanic (Low)
- Northern German is essentially Dog spoken in a guttural accent.
- --jmallett
- Dutch is essentially English spoken with a French accent by a German.
- --jmallett
- Dutch is essentially German written with English spelling.
- --Luís Henrique
- Dutch is essentially German as spoken by the members of a conspiracy
who pretend not to speak German.
- --John Cowan
- Dutsj is essensjullie a Loo Sjurmennik lenkwitsj wis
det vunkie letter (det riepleezes Y) plus a serieuslie
koel ortografie.
- --several members of Conlang
- Dutch is essentially German spoken by someone with a sore throat (or:
by someone clearing his throat while speaking).
- --Philip Newton
- Written Dutch is essentially German with misspellings one
would expect from small German children.
- --Terrence Griffin
- Dutch is essentially what you know to be English, only heard through
lots of loud background noise.
- --Dan Seriff
- Dutch is essentially English with all the vowels doubled.
- --Keith Gaughan
- Dutch is essentially English spoken whilst stoned,
which pretty much explains all the double vowels ;-)
- --Keith Gaughan
- I prefer to think of English as being essentially Dutch with all double
vowels halved.
- --Maarten van Beek
- Afrikaans is essentially Dutch baby talk.
- --John Cowan
- Conversely, Dutch is essentially Afrikaans as spoken by a corpse.
- --John Cowan
- Flemish is essentially Dutch dumbed down for use by Francophones.
- --Zoe Mulford
- Flemish is, as its name phonetically suggests, essentially Dutch while vomiting.
- --Mike Taylor
- Frisian is essentially (Middle) English as spoken by the Dutch.
- --John Cowan
- Conversely, English is essentially the Old Frisian of a sea-sick Old Saxon
speaker, as mangled by an obtuse Francophonified Danish mercenary
who took Latin and Greek in school and is currently on an
around-the-world cruise.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson/Matt Pearson
- Low German is essentially Dutch with an identity problem.
- --Danny Weir
- Dutch is essentially Low German with an army and a navy.
- --Andreas Johansson
- The Dutch are actually Anglophones pretending to be Germans.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Afrikaans is essentially Dutch with English grammar.
- --Jan van Steenbergen
- Dutch is essentially English spoken while yawning (therefore the extra vowels).
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Frisian is essentially Old English spoken by Anglo-Saxons who got lost on their
way from Schleswig-Holstein.
- --Andrew Johnson
- Dutch sounds like a drunk Englishman speaking German.
- --Warren Dumke (via Daniel E. Huston)
- Dutch is essentially a mix of German, Swedish and English, but tries to hide
it by having a lot of unnecessary double vowels and 'oe's everywhere.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Dutch is essentially a mixture of German and English spoken in a Swedish accent.
- --Estel Telcontar
- Dutch is essentially swish German.
- --Anon.
- Walloon essentially is bad French spoken by a Dutch person who wants to
impress the Germans.
- --Hanbing Feng
- Luxembourgish essentially is worse German spoken by another Dutch person who wants
to impress the French. --Hanbing Feng
- --Hanbing Feng
- Dutch is essentially German as spoken by a group of people who decided
to start their own literary tradition several hundred years ago.
- --Philip Newton
- Dutch is English spelt funny and spoken in a Klingon accent.
- --Javier Candeira
- Dutch is essentially the only langage in the world that sounds as if its
phonology had been originally devised as a German creole by some Asian people
that nonetheless can only have learned it after they were colonized by already
Dutch-speaking Europeans.
- --Guillaume Thomas
- Low German is essentially Germanic that stayed at home.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Lippisches Platt is essentially bad Dutch with the diphthongs all spoken
backwards.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Spanish
- Spanish is essentially Italian spoken by Arabs.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Castilian Spanish is mostly your average Spanish spoken while gagging on
paella rice.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Castilian Romance is nothing but Latin spoken by Basque lips and
transformed by evolution in an environment of Basque habits and of Basque
phonetic tradition.
- --P. Ormaechevarria, via David Mediavilla Ezquibela
- Andalusian Spanish is essentially Castilian with needless syllabic
appendages circumcised.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Puerto Rican is just Spanish as hurriedly spoken in substandard housing
in the Bronx.
- --ilvi
- Cuban Spanish is essentially Spanish as spoken on the express train.
- --Angel Ortiz
- Argentinean is essentially Italian spoken so that other South Americans
can catch on.
- --ilvi
- Spanish is essentially a dialect of Californian English used for increasing
the value of real estate.
(Gee, wouldn't this faux Spanish strip mall be worth $200,000 more if it was
called Plaza del Mucho Dinero?)
- --Jeffrey Henning
- Mexican is essentially Castilian Spanish as spoken while excreting hot
peppers, therefore without the superiority complex.
- --ilvi & Ivan C. Amaya
- Mexican essentially sounds like Japanese pronounced with a strong Irish
brogue.
- --Heather Grove
- Conversely, Japanese sounds like Mexican with all the vowels removed.
- --Heather Grove
- On the other hand, Mexican is essentially Nahuatl with enough Spanish and
English borrowings to keep from scaring off tourists (ask anyone from
Spain, it certainly isn't Spanish).
- --Heather Grove
- Ladino is essentially Spanish as spoken while haggling at overseas markets.
- --Jay Bowks
- Judeo-Spanish is essentially the perfect auxiliary language squelched by
Arabic and Hebrew.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Silbo is essentially Spanish as blown through the lips.
- --ilvi
- Papiamento is essentially Dutch Spanish.
- --John Cowan
- Papiamento is essentially Spanish as spoken after one too many shots of
Captain Jack.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Mexican Spanish is essentially all consonants.
- --John Cowan
- Caribbean Spanish is essentially all vowels.
- --John Cowan
- Ladino is essentially Spanish vowels with Portuguese consonants written
in Hebrew by people living in the Netherlands and Turkey.
- --Steg Belsky
- Spanish is essentially Japanese with a few consonant clusters added to
fool you into thinking it's Romance.
- --Steg Belsky
- Spanish is essentially the English of the future (it is now the second most
spoken first language).
- --Danny Wier
- Spanish is essentially Latin spoken by Iberians, with Basque phonetics.
- --Javier Candeira
- Spanish is basically just a crude form of Vulgar Latin jazzed up with a little
Basque and Arabic.
- --Brian
- Spanish is essentially a five-vowel variant of standard Italian,
but with no gemination (except ll, rr, which have become qualitatively
different.
- --John Cowan
- Spanish is what happened when Moors tried to learn Latin and said "screw
it."
- --Charles Lavergne
- Austronesian
- Hawaiian is essentially ... vowels.
- --Lauren M. Squires
- Hawaiian is a cousin of Indonesian with a fear of consonants.
- --Danny Weir
- Bislama is essentially an Austronesian language with
English vocabulary.
- --Jacques Guy
- Tok Pisin is essentially bad English mixed with even worse Melanesian,
decorated with a few German swearwords and strung together by somebody who
had never heard of grammar or syntax.
- --Tommy Tyrberg
- Samoan/Hawaiian/Maori is essentially bad Hawaiian/Maori/Samoan.
- --John Cowan
- Police-Motu is essentially canine elocution as emulated by (in)human beings.
- --ilvi
- Bahasa Indonesia is essentially a constructed language designed
to fool foreigners into thinking Indonesia is a monoculture.
- --John Cowan
- ...and the same is true of Tagalog/Pilipino, mutatis mutandis.
- --John Cowan
- Indonesian and Tagalog are essentially flowing water -- Indonesian a swiftly
flowing brook and Tagalog water going over rapids.
- --Adam Walker
- Ilocano sounds essentially like
Tagalog spoken by a Balikbayan from Indo-China.
- --Kristian Jensen
- Malay is essentially Indonesian as spoken by Englishmen.
- --Amber Adams
- Conversely, Indonesian is essentially Malay as spoken by Dutchmen.
- --Amber Adams
- Tagalog is essentially Spanish.
- --Anonymous, via Nate
- Tagalog is essentially Visayan spoken by Kapampangans.
- --goodboi
- Latin and Italian
- Oscan is Latin with every other consonant changed to f.
- --Justin Mansfield
- Classical Latin is essentially an artificial language devised to make
the vulgar Roman aristocracy sound intelligent.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Latin is essentially what you have if you read a satanist mass backwards.
(tse assim, eti!)
- --Luís Henrique
- Latin is essentially Greek with all of the interesting bits dropped into
the Adriatic.
- --Dan Seriff
- Classical Latin is essentially Liturgical Latin with correct
pronunciation.
- --Dan Seriff
- Conversely, Liturgical Latin is essentially Classical Latin with all
initial consonants pronounced as affricates.
- --Dan Seriff
- Modern Latin is essentially Classical Latin full of neologisms that
end in -trum.
- --Justin Mansfield
- Church Latin is essentially reverse-engineered Italian.
- --Justin Mansfield
- Erasmian Latin is essentially Church Latin as spoken by Germans.
- --Justin Mansfield
- Italian is essentially bad Latin.
- --Eugene Holman
- Spanish is essentially bad Italian.
- --Eugene Holman
- Italian is essentially Latin as spoken by people who were
shouting at their slaves all the time.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Italian is essentially machine gun fire heard from a long way off.
- --Dan Seriff
- Italian is essentially Tuscan dialect as spoken by a Lombard.
- --Luca Mangiat
- Italian is essentially Latin in a leather factory.
- --Mike Taylor
- Venetian is essentially Spanish as spoken by people not smart enough
to discover America.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Lombard is essentially Italian spoken with German accent and English grammar.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Lombard is essentially French as spoken by Italians who don't know French.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Piedmontese is essentially French as spoken by Italians who only
know French a little bit.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Ligurian is essentially Sicilian spoken with a Portuguese accent.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Corsican is essentially Ligurian spoken with a Sardinian accent and
some French words.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Romanesque is essentially Tuscan spoken with a Neapolitan accent.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Tuscan is essentially Italian with all consonants aspirated.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Neapolitan is essentially a sign language. The loud sounds that
Neapolitans emit are just music to accompany the gestures.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Bolognese is essentially Lombard spoken with a English accent.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Sicilian is essentially ancient Tuscan spoken with an English accent.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Italian is essentially English with vowels added to the ends of words.
Lombard is essentially Italian with vowels removed from the ends of words.
Ergo, Lombard is essentially English.
- --And Rosta/Marco Cimarosti
- Ecclesiastical Latin is essentially Classical Latin with a "pick your
pronounciation" sign over every phoneme.
- --Harald Stoiber
- Italian is essentially Latin that stayed at home.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Italian is essentially the feminine side of Spanish. Conversely Spanish
is essentially Italian for "Men".
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Italian is what happened when Romans tried to learn Latin and said "screw
it."
- --Charles Lavergne
- French
- French is essentially the first syllables of Latin
words spoken with a headcold.
- --Eugene Holman
- French is essentially Latin spoken by a drunken Roman soldier.
- --Elliotte Rusty Harold
- French is essentially the language that Americans don't learn before
travelling abroad.
- --Dan Seriff
- French is essentially English spoken while eating a very big piece of
Brie cheese.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- French is essentially Latin on a catwalk.
- --Mike Taylor
- Franche est essentialement englaishe ouithe les
endinges funnies et lottes de vowelles et les
adjectifs en alle les places ronges.
- --Clint Jackson Baker
- Belgian is essentially French spoken as a tonal language.
- --Zoe Mulford
- Wallon is essentially French as spoken by Spanish soldiers occupying Belgium.
- --Zoe Mulford
- Francophones are essentially Germans speaking the bad Latin they
were taught by Gauls.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- Swiss French is essentially French spoken with a very hot potato
in one's mouth.
- --Alain LaBonté
- Canadian French is essentially bad English as spoken by a Belgian with an
inferiority complex.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- French is essentially German with messed-up pronounciation and spelling.
- --Robert B Wilson
- French vocabulary is essentially English minus a few obvious germanicisms.
- --Andreas Johansson
- All Romance languages are essentially the same. Except French.
- --Andreas Johansson
- French is essentially Latin forced to comply with destructive sound changes
and German influence.
- --Trebor Jung
- French is essentially an attempt by the Dutch to speak a Romance language.
- --Danny Wier
- French is essentially a language that elides everything that doesn't get
out of the way fast enough, and nasalises everything else.
- --Peter Bleackley
- French is essentially Inuktitut disguised as Latin.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- French is essentially a Romance language with Algonquian verb grammar.
- --Danny Wier
- French is essentially je ne sais quoi.
- --Sally Caves
- Swiss French is essentially French "uptalk."
- --Sally Caves
- French is essentially the linguistic equivalent of a really bad tailgating
accident in which all the final consonants either are lost or stuck on
the windshield of the next car.
- --Hanbing Feng
- French is essentially Latin spoken by Germans (with their mouths full).
- --Mukund Marathe
- French is essentially the quintessence of every kind of Romance language,
disguised over centuries by its inspired creators into some Germanic
stepbrother out of sheer modesty.
- --Guillaume Thomas
- French is essentially the pidgin Latin that Caesar's army used to solicit
German whores.
- --Tom Arnold
- French is just Celtic with a heavy overlay of Vulgar Latin.
- --Brian
- If Quebecois is to French what American is to English, French is
essentially an extinct language.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- French is essentially bad Latin as spoken by Bretons and Gauls
who are insecure about their ancestry.
- --Xander
- French is what happened when Germans tried to learn Latin and said "screw
it."
- --Charles Lavergne
- Portuguese
- Portuguese is essentially bad Spanish, mumbled.
- --Eugene Holman
- Portuguese is essentially Spanish spoken through ill-fitting dentures.
- --Not Roger Mills
- Portuguese is essentially the language spoken by Gallegos who decided
to have their own independent country.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Portugese is essentially Spanish while eating a hot potato.
- --Mike Taylor
- Ergo Portuguese is essentially Danish posing as a Romance language.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Portuguese is essentially Spanish spoken while on Viagra®.
- --Danny Wier
- Brazilian is essentially Latin without consonants.
- --Paulo Rónai (via Luís Henrique)
- Portuguese is essentially Brazilian without vowels.
- --Luís Henrique
- Portuguese is essentially Spanish as spoken by a Russian.
- --Peter Clark
- Azorean Portuguese is essentially your Mainland Portuguese as spoken with
puckered lips.
- --ilvi
- Portuguese is nothing more than Spanish as spoken by people who wannabe
French.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Gallego is essentially Portuguese as suppressed by Francisco Franco
(a wannabe Castilian).
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Brazilian is essentially Spanish spoken by Portuguese hot babes with rhythm.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Brazilian is essentially a conlang created by people who wanted to have sex
all the time, but still be able to talk about everyday things.
- --alleszermalmer
- Portuguese and Galician are hayseed dialects of Spanish.
- --Brian
- They say if you're speaking bad Spanish, you're speaking Portuguese but I
didn't find that to be true!
- --Brian
- Portuguese is Spanish spoken with a French accent. (Not really true since the
nasals in Portuguese are different than those in French.)
- --Brian
- Portuguese is essentially a kind of contact language formed from Spanish
and... more Spanish!
- --Maria
- To a Galician speaker, Portuguese sounds like a kind of Galician with
most vowels left out, whereas to a Portuguese speaker Galician may
sometimes sound like Portuguese with a Spanish accent.
- --Anonymous
- Other Romance
- Provençal is essentially Medieval French as uttered during lovemaking.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Catalan is essentially bad Spanish mixed with even worse French.
- --Eugene Holman
- Catalan is essentially Spanish and French spoken at the same time.
- --Michael Everson
- Catalan is essentially Spanish when you're not paying attention.
- --Mike Taylor
- Catalan is essentially bad Spanish and bad French mixed by somebody who did not speak either one of them.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Catalan is essentially Castilian spoken by a dyslexic Frenchman.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Catalan, as everyone knows, is essentially Spanish spoken by Poles.
- --John Fisher
- Catalan is essentially Spanish with the last letter removed from
each word.
- --Ged Lewis
- Catalan is essentially Castillian spoken by people who don't want to speak
Castillian.
- --Luís Henrique
- Catalan is essentially French spoken with a Portuguese accent.
- --Luís Henrique
- Catalan is essentially Provençal spoken by Spaniards.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Occitan is essentially Catalan spoken by the French.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Rumantsch is essentially Vulgar Latin of old as cryogenized
in the Swiss Alps.
- --ilvi
- Brithenig is essentially bad Italian spoken by Welsh who
swallow the final syllables.
- --Andrew Smith
- Wenedyk is essentially Latin written by someone who fell asleep on
the keyboard.
- --Jan van Steenbergen
- Romanian is essentially a Romance language trying really hard to blend in
with the Slavic languages around it.
- --Jesse S. Bangs
- Romanian is essentially an exiled, forever-homesick 'Ovidiu' writing his
stanzas from an immense vocabulary of
slavic-turkish-hungarian-greek-french-german-yiddish-kaldarash Latin,
and -- unlike all of his far-living lazy and vulgarized brothers,
sisters and cousins -- still cherishes a faint idea and longing for his
classical mother's so-noble traits.
- --Alfred W. Tüting (.aulun.)
- Reman is essentially the prodigal son of Latin.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- Narbonósc is essentially French spoken by a Provençal
who drank too much Pastis.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- Romanian is essentially Italian with unintelligible endings.
- --Primo Levi
- Rumantsch is essentially Gaelic with an Italian accent.
- --Eamon Graham
- Catalan is essentially Spanish with the accents slanted the other way.
- --Adam Walker
- Judajca is essentially Latin that's been circumcised.
- --Steg Belsky
- Romanian is essentially Dracula in Gucci underwear.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Catalan was invented by horny Spanish guys who tried to sound French so
they could pick up Northern European girls who could only speak French
as a foreign tongue.
- --Andrew Johnson
- Catalan is essentially the secret passwords needed to get into places
half-price in Barcelona.
- --Peter Bleackley
- Catalan has more of a frantaliano feel to it, whereas Portuguese is
more esfrañol.
- --Mark J. Reed
- Portuguese is essentially the language of angry Spaniards.
- --Bill Hammel
- Romanian is essentially Latin spoken by Slavs.
- --Trebor Jung
- Portuguese is essentially Spanish disguised as French.
- --Danny Wier
- Catalan is a complicated mixture of Spanish and French: sometimes it
appears to be the intersection, sometimes the union, sometimes it is
weirdly unique.
- --Javier Candeira
- Catalan is essentially German read in Spanish by a French speaker.
- --Clint Jackson Baker
- Romanian is essentially French pronounced as written.
- --Christian Thalmann
- Romanian is essentially Latin spoken by people who
prefer to live in cold lands instead of Mediterranean
basin and prefer to drink vodka instead of wine.
- --Fatih Yuksel
- Romanian is essentially Russian pretending to be a Romance language.
- --Keith Gaughan
- Moldavian is essentially a Romanian dialect which spurted out of Russian
imperialism, except that some angry men and women who found themselves
on the bad side of the border decided to pick up all the broken pieces
of their cultural identity and to call their dialect with the name of
their nation, which is touching but still linguistically misleading.
- --Guillaume Thomas
- Romanian is essentially the expression of the stunning ability of a Roman
soldier to keep his linguistic roots alive when he switched to shepherding in
a hostile Dacian environment.
- --Guillaume Thomas
- Yiddish and Romanian are aberrant dialects of German and Italian with some
Slavic modifications.
- --Brian
- Romanian is essentially Latin spoken with an Albanian accent.
- --Brian Joseph
- Romanian is essentially Italian stirred in a blender.
- --Anonymous
- Slavic
- Bulgarian is essentially Russian pronounced as it is
spelled and using English grammar.
- --Eugene Holman
- Bulgarian is essentially Romanian with Russian vocabulary.
- --Danny Wier
- Slovenian is essentially Russian with an Italian accent.
- --Egbert Lenderink
- This [Russian with an Italian accent] is actually
how I tend to view Bulgarian.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- This description fits Serbo-Croat much better.
- --Ivan Derzhanski
- Serbo-Croatian is essentially an auxiliary language devised so that
different ethnic groups can understand each other as they swear at one
another.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Serbian and Croatian are essentially different languages merged by mutual
hatred.
- --Jay Bowks
- Bosnian is essentially a dead language, shot dead in no man's land.
- --Javier de la Rosa
- Croatian is essentially Serbo-Croatian written in the alphabet used in
Catholic Gospels.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Serbian is essentially Serbo-Croatian written in the alphabet used in
Orthodox Gospels.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Bosnian is essentially Serbo-Croatian curiously not written in the
alphabet used in the Koran.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Bosnian is essentially what Serbs and Croats prefer to communicate with
each other in.
- --Danny Weir
- Polish is essentially Russian spoken by a Frenchman.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- Polish is essentially a light form of Russian that even Germans can master.
- --Jay Bowks
- Polish is essentially any other Slavic language with 70% of its
consonants randomly shuffled.
- --Basilius
- Polish is essentially Czech spoken under the shower by
a couple that is unable to choose between fighting and
making love.
- --Jan van Steenbergen
- Russian is essentially Church Slavonic with a strong Mordvin accent.
- --Basilius
- Russian is essentially Englishovat'.
- --David Peterson
- Russian is essentially an articulated wail.
- --Dan Seriff
- Russian is essentially a language invented by Poles who couldn't spell.
- --Dan Sikorski
- Ukrainian is essentially Russian spoken by people with
cleft palates.
- --John Cowan
- Ukrainian is essentially an East Slavic relexification of Polish.
- --Basilius
- Written Belorussian is essentially Russian with misspellings one
would expect from small Russian children.
- --Ivan Derzhanski (based on Terrence Griffin on Dutch)
- Czech is essentially Slovak as spoken by a German.
- --John Cowan
- Conversely, Slovak is essentially Czech as spoken by a Hungarian.
- --John Cowan
- (Modern) Church Slavonic is essentially a Slavic relexification of
New Testament Greek.
- --Basilius
- Old Church Slavonic is essentially the language that comes out when
the basses sing a low C.
- --Dan Seriff
- Polish is essentially a remarkably "wet" language.
- --Jan van Steenbergen
- German and Polish are
essentially the same, only there are too many "ß"s in Leftoderian writing,
and too many "z"s in Rightoderian.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Trasianka is Russian as said by the Belarusan mouth, Narkamauka is
Belarusan as imitated by a Russian mouth and Taraszkievica is the
Belarusan mouth itself.
- --Pavel Iosad (on Belarusian dialects)
- From 15000 meters up, all Slavic languages are essentially the same.
- --John Cowan
- Belarussian is essentially Polish spoken by a Russian
suffering from a severe attack of akanie.
- --Jan van Steenbergen
- Ukrainian is essentially Russian with extra letters.
- --Bill Hammel
- Polish is essentially Russian spoken by people who thought it was French and
had to sound awful.
- --Trebor Jung
- Polish is essentially Portuguese when you stand 3 meters away, and
Russian when you come closer.
- --Philippe Caquant
- Czech is essentially Russian with beer instead of vodka.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Russian is essentially Punjabi spoken in the throat.
Contrariwise,
Punjabi is essentially Russian spoken in the nose.
- --C. B. Wright
- Russian is essentially Punjabi that fell off the wagon.
Contrariwise,
Punjabi is essentially Russian with better spices.
- --C. B. Wright
- Rrrrussian essentially is a language that requirrres its speakerrr to have a
tongue that worrrks like a vibrrratorrr.
- --Hangbing Feng
- Russian and Belarussian are essentially badly spelled Ukrainian.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Russian is essentially drunken Polish babytalk written with
a Greek alphabet.
- --Mark Garrity
- Ukrainian is essentially Russian with a bad attitude.
- --Mark Garrity
- Ukrainian is essentially Indo-European that stayed at home.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Celtic
- Latin is essentially Gaulish, but tour guides need to say both.
- --Asterix
- Norse is essentially Gaulish with rings on top of a's and o's slashed.
- --Asterix
- Greek is essentially Gaulish with an angular version of the
Latin script.
- --Asterix
- Gothic is essentially Gaulish in Fraktur.
- --Asterix
- Hebrew is essentially Gaulish.
- --Asterix
- Coptic is Gaulish that got lost in the desert.
- --Danny Wier
- Egyptian is Gaulish in pictures.
- --Irina Rempt
- Breton is essentially Welsh spoken with an aoutRAAAAgeous Franch acSANT.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- Welsh is essentially some reasonable language that had its
stock of vowels pillaged by Polynesians, yes, but
which one? Irish? They really don't sound that much alike.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- Breton is essentially Welsh with all the consonants changed to "z".
- --Thomas Leigh
- Welsh is essentially Breton spoken by Methodists
(being sober, they have no problem with [T] and [D], keep their vowels and
[r]'s clear, don't turn their diphthongs inside out ...).
- --Keith
- Cornish is
essentially Breton spoken by lapsed Methodists (if they haven't lapsed
to begin with, a few "cultural" visits to Brittany seem to do the trick).
- --Keith
- Welsh is essentially what appears on the screen after you have
inadvertently been resting your elbow on the keyboard.
- --And Rosta
- Welsh is essentially the only language that can have four consecutive L's.
- --Danny Weir
- Irish is essentially an Indo-European language cunningly disguised
as gibberish to perplex the English.
- --And Rosta
- Irish is essentially as many phonemes as possible written with
as few letters as possible.
- --Danny Weir
- Scottish Gaelic is essentially Irish Gaelic as spoken by
Britons, Picts, and Norsemen.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Manx is essentially Scottish Gaelic pronounced like
Irish Gaelic and spelled like English.
- --Thomas Leigh
- All Celtic languagues are essentially the same with different
idioms, what.
- --Asterix
- Irish essentially sounds like a "normal" language recorded on tape and
played backwards.
- --Christian Thalmann
- Gaelic sounds like Dutch on Acid.
- --Anonymous, via Thomas Leigh
- Manx is essentially Irish disguised as English
gibberish.
- --Danny Wier
- Welsh is practically spoken in Swansea and essentially spoken in Aberystwyth.
- --Sally Caves
- Gaelic is essentially what would happen at the intersection of English
spelling, Polish pronunciation and quite random yet strongly h-rich
vocabulary. (This, however, would suggest that Gaelic is being reborn
around the modern London suburbs or that it is Basque as sung by some
weary Scotsmen.)
- --Jakub Bartoszewicz
- Greek
- Modern Greek is essentially Classical Greek with all vowels and
diphthongs changed to "i", and all consonants pronounced as fricatives.
- --Egbert Lenderink/Justin Mansfield
- Modern Greek is essentially Classical Greek as spoken by Venetians.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- Koine Greek is essentially Classical Greek as spoken by people
who don't know any Greek.
- --Andreas Johannson
- Modern Greek is essentially Koine Greek after too much ouzo.
- --Danny Wier
- Mycenaean was essentially Greek written in katakana. (Apart from pigs and
vases, which were written in kanji.)
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Ancient Greek is Proto-Indo-European pidgin with an attitude.
Koine Greek is Ancient Greek mangled far and wide.
Modern Greek is Koine Greek mumbled and hissed (p-ssed). ;)
- --Hanuman Czhang
- Latin is essentially bad Greek.
- --paiktis22
- Greek essentially is a lengthy math equation with too many variables.
- --Hanbing Feng
- The Greek language is essentially the reason why the rest of Europe
decided to adopt Latin instead.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Greek is essentially Turkish.
- --Anonymous, via Noetica
- Modern Greek is essentially encrypted Castilian Spanish.
- --Henrik Theiling
- Baltic, Indo-Iranian, Dravidian
- Lithuanian is essentially bad Sanskrit.
- --John Cowan
- Proto-Sanskrit was essentially Proto-Latin spoken with a Proto-Tamil
accent.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Sanskrit is essentially PIE as spoken by people who like /a/.
- --Andreas Johannson
- Tamil is essentially Sanskrit spoken with a stutter.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Conversely, Sanskrit is essentially Tamil spoken with a lisp.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Urdu is essentially Hindi as spoken by Muslims.
- --John Cowan
- ...conversely, Hindi is essentially Urdu as spoken by Hindus.
- --John Cowan
- Hindi is essentially a combination of bad Persian and worse Sanskrit.
- --Amber Adams
- Bombay Hindi is essentially bad English.
- --Amber Adams
- ...conversely, Bombay English is essentially bad Hindi.
- --Amber Adams
- Bengali is essentially Hindi with all words stressed at the
beginning.
- --John Cowan
- Gujarati is essentially Hindi spoken by lazy Frenchmen.
- --Shreyas Sampat
- Romany is essentially a mix of Hindi and everything else.
- --Danny Weir
- Romany is essentially Kashmiri that took a long trip.
- --Danny Wier
- Malayalam is essentially Tamil as spoken by people who like palindromes.
- --Amber Adams
- Middle Persian is essentially Aramaic as written by monolingual Iranians.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Pashto is as essentially Persian as Icelandic is essentially English.
- --John Cowan
- Kurdish is essentially Persian as spoken by Klingons.
- --Robin Turner
- Tajik is essentially Farsi written in the Cyrillic alphabet, with a
little Uzbek stirred in for flavor.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Estonian is essentially Finnish with more length distinctions.
- --Lars Henrik Mathiesen
- Latvian is essentially Lithuanian (or Livonian) spoken by Estonians.
- --Lars Henrik Mathiesen/Otto Stolz
- Punjabi is essentially Hindi for pop music.
- --Amber Adams
- Bengali ish esshentially the shame ash Hindi, exshept no /s/.
- --Amber Adams
- Tamil is essentially the language that makes German look logical and easy.
- --Amber Adams
- Farsi is essentially Classical Latin as spoken by an Arab first-year student.
- --Amber Adams
- Romany is essentially Hindustani that took a walkabout.
- --Danny Wier
- Bengali is essentially Hindi spoken with a rosogolla in one's mouth.
- --Alok Joshi
- Sanskrit is Tamil with aspiration and voice, with borrowings from
Proto-Indo-European.
- --Shanth
- Punjabi is essentially Indo-Iranian that stayed at home.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Eastern Punjabi is essentially Western Punjabi that has been pwned by Hindi.
- --John Cowan
- Lithuanian is essentially Latvian as spoken by Poles.
- --The Multilingual Kitten
- Latgalian is essentially Latvian with vowels randomly shuffled.
- --The Multilingual Kitten
- Livonian is essentially Estonian as written by Latvians who couldn't
decide whether to use Latvian or Estonian orthography, so used both at
the same time.
- --The Multilingual Kitten
- Livonian is actually Latvian as spoken by drunken southern Estonians.
- --alcarilinque
- Uralic
- Finnish is essentially Estonian spoken in the genitive case.
- --Eugene Holman
- Conversely, Estonian is essentially Finnish with most
unstressed and final syllables suppressed.
- --Eugene Holman
- Finnish is essentially bastardized Hungarian.
- --Ferenc Valoczy
- Finnish is essentially Japanese spoken with an Italian accent.
- --John Davies
- Finnish is essentially Turkish in the snow.
- --Mike Taylor
- Conversely, Turkish is essentially Finnish in the sun.
- --Mike Taylor
- Sámi is essentially Finnish spoken with a lisp and a sore throat.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Conversely, Finnish is essentially Sámi with a PIE substrate.
- --Daniel Andreasson
- Ffiinnnniisshh iiss eesssseennttiiaallllyy aa llaanngguuaaggee ffoorr
ppeeooppllee wwiitthh ddoouubbllee vviissiioonn.
- --Clint Jackson Baker
- Hungarian is essentially Finnish spoken by Czechs.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Hungarian is essentially the noise one's dad makes when he has
accidentally hit his thumb with a hammer.
- --And Rosta
- Finnish is essentially Proto-Estonian.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Estonian is essentially Finnish spoken by Swedes.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Hungarian is essentially German with all sounds randomly shuffled.
- --Egbert Lenderink
- Hungarian is essentially a Scotch snap with double-long rounded vowels.
- --Dan Seriff
- Hungarian is essentially all counterintuitive consonant pairings.
- --Dan Seriff
- Finnish is essentially Hungarian spoken while drunk, freezing,
and morose.
- --Dan Seriff
- Sámi is essentially Hungarian spoken while drunk, freezing,
and standing next to a reindeer.
- --Dan Seriff
- Finnish is essentially Swedish with all sounds randomly shuffled.
- --Egbert Lenderink
- Votic is essentially extinct (25 speakers and falling).
- --John Cowan
- Estonian is essentially an inflecting form of Finnish whose lexicon is just
Finnish mangled by syncope and apocope with a whole bunch of foreign words
pretending to be native.
- --Trebor Jung
- Hungarian is essentially a mangling of Uralic, Turkic, Slavic, and German
words, with a remarkably Uralic-esque grammar.
- --Trebor Jung
- Hungarian is essentially Norwegian spelled backwards, with a lot of
ös.
- --Nils Wærstad
- Hungarian is essentially German disguised as a Uralic language with Turkic
and Slavic influence.
- --Trebor Jung
- Estonian is essentially mumbled Finnish as written down by a German.
- --Philip Newton
- Hűngarian eszensialy egy langűagy dizaind all főrein
tőűrisztsz tű perpleksz every aszpekt-in iz.
- --Hanbing Feng
- Mordvin is essentially Uralic that stayed at home.
in: West Germanic (Low)
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Hungarian is essentially Finnish as spoken by Norwegians and written
by Poles.
- --The Multilingual Kitten
- ...no, by anti-Poles. No self-respecting Pole would flip s and sz around.
- --spamsink
- Afroasiatic
- Hebrew is essentially Arabic mangled by Europeans. But then,
so is Maltese.
- --John Cowan
- Maltese is essentially Arabic as spoken by an Italian
living in England.
- --Fabian
- Modern Hebrew is the language of the Bible and the Talmud, refurbished by a
mad pedant and bastardized by 5 million immigrants.
- --Marc Miller
- Modern Hebrew is essentially Biblical Hebrew with Euro-Zionist
mismanagement.
- --Jay Bowks
- Berber is essentially Egyptian spoken while imitating snorting camels.
- --ilvi
- Berber is essentially a cousin of the Semitic languages with a fear of vowels.
- --Danny Weir
- Egypt, home of mystery religion, had a language with mystery vowels.
- --Danny Weir
- Coptic is essentially Egyptian spoken by Greeks.
(Or Greek spoken by Egyptians?)
- --Thomas Leigh
- Egyptian is essentially Coptic with no vowels written.
- --Justin Mansfield
- Coptic is essentially Egyptian with no vowels pronounced.
- --Justin Mansfield
- Modern Hebrew is essentially bits of Ancient Hebrew from every period,
spoken by an Eastern European.
- --Justin Mansfield
- Hebrew is essentially Arabic with most consonants changed to "sh" and "kh".
- --Danny Wier
- Syriac is essentially Hebrew with Georgian-like vowel placements.
- --Danny Wier
- Hausa is essentially Arabic spoken in a manner much like playing
the didgeridoo.
- --Danny Wier
- Maldivian is essentially Sinhala written with Arabic-Indic digits with
accents.
- --Marco Cimarosti
- Hebrew is essentially Arabic spoken with a Yiddish accent.
- --Christophe Pierret
- Arabic is essentially the result of a bottle of tabasco flushed down
with a bottle of Stroh rum.
- --Christian Thalmann
- Arabic is essentially Spanish spoken backwards.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Al-Arabiyya al-essentialliyya al-lanqu'aj al-moor as-similar al-Hebruwwa
adh-dhan al-Inqlishiyya.
- --Danny Wier
- Algerian is essentially Arabic before vowels were invented.
- --Christophe Pierret
- Egyptian is essentially Arabic spoken on top of a pyramid.
- --Christophe Pierret
- Egyptian is essentially Arabic pronounced by sphinxes (which explains
why [dZ] is replaced by [g] to mystify other Arabs).
- --Christophe Pierret
- Saudi Arabian is essentially Arabic with all words meaning "sex" and
"alcohol" removed.
- --Christophe Pierret
- Lebanese is essentially business Arabic.
- --Christophe Pierret
- Lebanese is essentially Arabic with a French accent.
- --Leo Caesius
- Aramaic sounds essentially like Greek, as spoken by a camel with morning
sickness.
- --Somtow Sucharitkul
- Modern Hebrew is essentially Ashkenazic Hebrew as spoken by Sephardim.
- --Steg Belsky
- Modern Hebrew is essentially Sephardic Hebrew as spoken by Ashkenazim.
- --Steg Belsky
- Modern Israeli Hebrew is essentially all previous stages of Hebrew
relexified into British English with all the words changed to end in
"-atziya".
- --Steg Belsky
- Standard Arabic is essentially Biblical Hebrew with a few more
consonants.
- --Steg Belsky
- NYC-Area Judeo-Syrian is "essentially" Arabic
curses, bad Ebonics, and anglicized Hebrew religious terminology spoken
with a Brooklyn accent.
- --Steg Belsky
- Morrocan Arabic is essentially Arabic pronounced as
spelled -- without any vowels.
- --Adam Walker
- Arabic is essentially the Latin of the future (there will be more Muslims
than Christians sometime this century).
- --Danny Wier
- Hebrew is essentially
Arabic disguised as Aramaic.
- --Danny Wier
- Maltese writing is essentialy Latin with some dots on top.
- --anonymous
- Maltese is essentially the bastard child of Arabic and Italian who spent
too mcuh time hanging around with English.
- --Joe
- Aramaic is essentially Hebrew after being violated by Greeks and left
by the side of the road.
- --Tom Arnold
- Modern Hebrew is essentially 11th Century Hebrew poorly pronounced by European
Socialists.
- --Tom Arnold
- 11th Century Hebrew is essentially Mishnaic Hebrew after Rashi added some words.
- --Tom Arnold
- Mishnaic Hebrew is essentially Biblical Hebrew minus some confusing grammatical
rules.
- --Tom Arnold
- Biblical Hebrew is essentially supposed to confuse anyone who reads it without
referring to the Oral Law.
- --Tom Arnold
- Israeli (somewhat misleadingly a.k.a. "Modern Hebrew") is essentially a
hybrid of "sleeping beauty"/"walking dead" Hebrew, "mame loshn" (mother
tongue) Yiddish and a plethora of other contributors.
- --Ghil'ad Zuckermann
- Modern Israeli Hebrew is essentially Sephardic Hebrew as fit into
Ashkenazic/Yiddish Phonology.
- --Anonymous, via Jonathan North Washington
- Berber is essentially French.
- --Hassan Ibrahimi
- Afroasiatic, Ancient
- Biblical Aramaic is essentially Biblical Hebrew with a lithp.
- --Dan Seriff
- Peripheral Akkadian is essentially bad Akkadian.
- --John Huehnergard
- Amarna Akkadian is essentially Peripheral Akkadian as written by monolingual
Canaanites.
- --John Huehnergard
- Canaanite is essentially bad Arabic.
- --John Huehnergard
- "Amorite" is essentially everything written in Akkadian which isn't
Akkadian.
- --John Huehnergard
- Neo-Assyrian and Neo-Babylonian are essentially debased forms of Akkadian as
written by monolingual Aramaeans.
- --Charles Häberl
- Akkadian is essentially East Semitic as spoken and written by Sumerians.
- --Charles Häberl
- Moabite is essentially Aramaic, concealing its roots and aspiring to be a
dialect of Hebrew.
- --Charles Häberl
- The language of Deir Alla is essentially Hebrew, laying low and pretending
to be a dialect of Aramaic.
- --Charles Häberl
- Biblical Hebrew is essentially Canaanite as spoken by Zoroastrians.
- --Charles Häberl
- Mandaic is essentially Aramaic as spoken by Zoroastrians.
- --Charles Häberl
- Late Biblical Hebrew is essentially Biblical Hebrew, as written by
monolingual Aramaeans, without the benefit of Lambdin's grammar.
- --Charles Häberl
- Imperial Aramaic is essentially "business Aramaic" as spoken by Persian
clerks and middle management.
- --Charles Häberl
- Biblical Aramaic is essentially a bad imitation of Persian Chancery Aramaic
as written by a mediocre Judean novelist during the Hellenistic Era.
- --Charles Häberl
- Phoenician is essentially "business Hebrew."
- --Charles Häberl
- Punic is essentially Phoenician as spoken by Berbers.
- --Charles Häberl
- Proto-Semitic is essentially Arabic spoken by an Ethiopian.
- --Danny Weir
- Biblical Hebrew is essentially Standard Arabic with a few consonants lost
at the bottom of the Reed Sea.
- --Steg Belsky
- Talmudic Aramaic is essentially Arabic at the dentist ("say 'aaaaa...'")
trying to be Hebrew but dropping the wrong consonants.
- --Steg Belsky
- Ancient Egyptian is essentially a picture book.
- --Steg Belsky
- Sino-Tibetan, Japanese, Korean, Vietnamese
- Mandarin is essentially Chinese as spoken by Mongols.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- Korean is essentially bad Japanese, also as spoken by Mongols.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- Conversely, Japanese is essentially Korean in the mouths of little children.
- --Daniel von Brighoff
- Japanese is essentially tone-deaf ancient Chinese spoken backwards.
- --Matthew Faupel
- Japanese is essentially phonetic heaven.
- --Nik Taylor
- Japanese is essentially 16th-century Chinese,
17th-century Portuguese, 18th-century Dutch, 19th-century French and
20th-century English with an abhorrence of consonant clusters.
- --Matthew Faupel
- Japanese is essentially the linguistic equivalent of kicking someone's
butt.
- --Danny Wier
- This is a more apt description of Korean as I heard it used by
kindergarten teachers and drunk middle-aged males alike.
- --Brendan Wolfe
- Korean is essentially being caught in a syllable-diagramming exercise
gone horribly, horribly wrong.
- --David Boshko
- Shanghainese is essentially Mandarin spoken with laryngitis.
- --John Cowan
- Mandarin is essentially Chinese as spoken by servants.
- --Yuen Ren Chao
- Mandarin (contrasted with Cantonese) sounds essentially
like wind whistling through dry bamboo.
- --Adam Walker
- Taiwanese sounds essentially like a room full of rubber balls.
- --Adam Walker
- Cantonese is essentially Chinese as spoken by a Zhuang.
- --John Cowan
- Cantonese is essentially what everyone else in China calls swearing.
- --Kiri Aradia Morgan
- Chinese is essentially Symbolic Logic spoken as a tonal language.
- --Zoe Mulford
- Modern Tibetan is essentially Old Tibetan as spoken by people
whose tongues went numb from trying to actually pronounce Old Tibetan
as written.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Tibetan is essentially Burmese with Georgian-like vowel placements.
- --Danny Wier
- Vietnamese is essentially Chinese spoken as fast as you can.
- --Alex Stanich
- Spoken Vietnamese is essentially Chinese with 6 tones, unpronounceable
consonants, and sounds you have to say while inhaling.
- --Jonathan Walton
- Written Vietnamese is essentially Wade-Giles as invented by an
opium-smoking Frenchman.
- --Jonathan Walton
- Chinese is essentially just like any other language, except that there's
no tense, gender, conjugation, grammar, or logic, and all the words sound the
same.
- --Jonathan Walton
- Taiwanese is essentially Mandarin (though the letter 'H' was mortally
wounded during the civil war).
- --Jonathan Walton
- Chinese, as spoken by hip 20-somethings, is essentially really bad English.
- --Jonathan Walton
- Japanese, as spoken by hip 50-somethings, is essentially really bad English.
- --Wolcen
- Japanese is essentially Classical Chinese with a second helping of vowels.
- --Jonathan Walton
- Modern Chinese is essentially Classical Chinese without any manners.
- --Jonathan Walton
- Chinese is essentially a picture book drawn by people who forgot they
were drawing pictures.
- --Steg Belsky
- Japanese is essentially Tagalog spoken by Koreans trying to do an impression of
Americans from the point of view of Chinese people.
- --Andrew Johnson
- Classical Japanese is essentially Classical Chinese with zi4 ("z")
pronounced as ji ("g").
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Korean is essentially being caught in a syllable-diagraming exercise gone
horribly, horribly wrong.
- --David Boshko
- I have long maintained that Japanese grammar is essentially Spanish done in
reverse Polish notation.
- --Elyse Grasso
- Vietnamese is essentially Thai with a Chinese vocabulary.
- --Danny Wier
- Korean is essentially Mongolian with a Chinese vocabulary.
- --Danny Wier
- Chinese is essentially German, only more so.
- --John Cowan
- Classical Chinese is essentially verbs with optional arguments
and complements.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Japanese is essentially a language that adopted the world's most
complicated writing system, and then made it worse.
- --Peter Bleackley
- Mandarin Chinese is essentially French spoken backwards.
- --Troels Busk-Jepsen
- Korean is essentially angry Japanese with a speech impediment.
- --Aeron Lempert
- Japanese is (of course) essentially Turkish as spoken by Hawaiians.
- --David Eddyshaw
- Japanese is essentially Korean as spoken by academics with absolutely
no knowledge of Korean.
- --mythusmage
- Mandarin is essentially the French of Sinitic.
- --Bill Poser
- Tibetan is essentially the French of Tibeto-Burman.
- --Russell Lee-Goldman
- Altaic
- Turkish is essentially Arabic, Persian and French words
stuck together with Mongolian grammar.
- --Thomas Leigh
- All (other) Turkic languages are essentially obsolete Turkish.
- --John Cowan
- Modern Turkish is essentially Ottoman Turkish minus the Arabic, Persian
and French words.
- --qaya
- Turkish is essentially Azerbaijani spoken by would-be Europeans, so with
a French, German and English accent.
- --qaya
- Tatar is essentially Azerbaijani with a strong Mordvin accent.
- --qaya
- Uzbek is essentially Azerbaijani spoken by those who gave up on its 53
verb tenses.
- --qaya
- Kalmyk is essentially Mongolian that got lost.
- --Danny Wier
- Azerbaijani is essentially
Turkish spoken by Shi'as who never have had anything to do
with Ataturk.
- --Danny Wier
- Uzbek is essentially Uighur which used to be spoken
with a Russian accent.
- --Fatih Yuksel
- Uighur is essentially Uzbek which still is spoken
with a Chinese accent.
- --Fatih Yuksel
- Karaim is essentially Turkic spoken by Lithuanian Jews
with European syntax and with a few Hebrew words added --
just to make sure they are both Europeans and Jews.
- --Fatih Yuksel
- Turkish is Azerbaijani spoken while sunbathing on the
coast.
- --Fatih Yuksel
- Azerbaijani is Turkish spoken while working in an oil field.
- --Fatih Yuksel
- Uighur is essentially bad Turkish mixed with worse Kazakh and execrable
Chinese.
- --Daniel Baker
- Manchu was essentially Mongolian, as adapted for use by multiethnic
hillbillies with a penchant for voiceless bilabials and combined arms
tactics.
- --Kenji Schwartz
- Evenki is essentially Ur-Tungusic as spoken by reindeer
fetishists with wanderlust.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Negidal is essentially Evenki without the wanderlust.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Even is essentially pharyngialized Evenki, spoken by Santa's
ranchers, at the beach.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Solon is essentially Evenki spoken by Mongol groupies. Oroqen
is just Solon without horses but with Chinese passports.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Jurchen might be, in essence, Nanai as spoken by Mongol
groupies but recorded by Chinese.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Yakut (Sakha) is essentially Old Uighur spoken by Evenkis to
cattle, while trying to sound like Finns.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Nanai is essentially Ur-Tungusic as spoken by those Tunguses
who objected to reindeer, cattle, and other newfangled Turco-Samoyedic
vices, and who invested in riverfront property instead.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Oroch is essentially Nanai spoken on the tributaries. Ulcha is
essentially downriver Nanai. Kur-Urmi is essentially backwater Nanai.
(Nanai proper fished all the sound changes out of the river before they
could reach Oroch, Ulcha, or Kur-Urmi.)
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Udihe is essentially the bastard child of trappers' and
ginseng-diggers' Chinese and upriver women's Nanai.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Goldi is essentially what the old guard called Nanai, while
Hezhen is essentially what the Red Guard called Goldi.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Orok is essentially Nanai that crossed the Tatar Straits to
look for more riverfront properties.
- --Kenji Schwarz
- Kazakh is essentially Kyrgyz without affricates.
- --Jonathan North Washington
- Uzbek is essentially three major branches of Turkic as spoken by
Tajiks.
- --Jonathan North Washington
- Turkish is essentially a dialect of French
(restoran, omlet, garson, factura, pantolon, televizyon,...).
- --Siganus Sutor
- ...spoken by Armenian berberians.
- --Language Hat
- Miscellaneous
- Proto-Indo-European is essentially Latin as spoken by Klingons.
- --Joe Hill
- Etruscan is essentially mummified, dried up Modern Albanian
as used by hoary Italians.
- --ilvi
- Etruscan is essentially composed of the various sounds emanated
by the cartoon character Pinky from Animaniacs.
- --Justin Mansfield
- Cherokee is essentially a language written in a mixture of Latin,
Coptic and Cyrillic letters with exaggerated serifs.
- --Danny Wier
- Bella Coola is essentially the linguistic equivalent of a drum solo.
- --Danny Wier
- Chechen is essentially Klingon spoken by Caucasian Muslims.
- --Danny Wier
- Swahili is essentially Bantu as spoken while haggling over prices.
- --Jay Bowks
- Gur languages are essentially typical Niger-Congo languages, only
with the nouns spoken backwards.
- --John Cowan
- Wolof is essentially the announcement of African unity restricted to the
northwestern part of the continent.
- --Guillaume Thomas
- Tukulor is essentially Wolof when some Fula guys tried to experiment with
linguistic variation over it, and they were successful.
- --Guillaume Thomas
- Hottentot is essentially voiced rock and roll, just the beat
without the music.
- --ilvi
- Xhosa is essentially a Bantu language as spoken by a Bushman.
- --John Cowan
- Zulu and Xhosa are essentially Bantu languages that dabble a little
in Khoisan phonology.
- --Danny Wier
- Georgian actually does have vowels but they procrastinate.
- --Danny Weir
- Grgn s ssntlly lngg wrttn wtht ny vwls
- --Clint Jackson Baker
- Georgian spoken backwards essentially is Russian.
- --Danny Weir
- Navajo is essentially not a language: it's a cryptographic system.
- --Tommy Tyrberg
- Nativeamericanlanguagesessentiallycramlotsofideasintooneword.
- --Clint Jackson Baker
- Inuktitut iis eesseentiiaallyy Fiinniish aas spooqqeen iin Greenlaand.
- --Clint Jackson Baker
- Comanche is essentially bad Shoshoni spoken from the back of a horse.
- --Anon.
- Burushaski is essentially Basque spoken by Indians.
- --Amber Adams
- Germanic is essentially a direct descendent of an Indo-European creole.
- --Hanuman Zhang
- If Welsh is P-Celtic, Irish is Q-Celtic, and Latin is Q-Italic, then
Germanic is essentially F-Celtic-Italic.
- --John Cowan
- Classical Georgian is essentially a literal translation of New Testament
Greek into Kartvelian.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Gothic romanization is essentially an attempt to
write both Gothic and proto-Gothic at the same time.
- --John Cowan
- Khmer is essentially Pali with a few consonant clusters borrowed from Georgian.
- --Amber Adams
- Most Germanic languages are essentially English spoken by Barbarians.
- --Joe
- Georgian is essentially a hybrid of altered IE grammar and Arabic, Persian,
Turkish, and Russian vocabulary
with a grammar that pretends to be related to IE but is actually like
Basque, just more polysynthetic.
- --Trebor Jung and Danny Wier
- Shilha is essentially the Bella Coola of Afro-Asiatic. Or Bella Coola is the
Shilha of Salishan.
- --Danny Wier
- Chechen is essentially a mix of Arabic and Georgian consonants and French
vowels.
- --Danny Wier
- Abkhaz is essentially the Haida of the Caucasus. Sixty-odd consonants; two
vowels.
- --Danny Wier
- Astrotalk is essentially Scoobytalk with a futuristic accent.
- --Mark Shoulson
- Sumerian is essentially Akkadian after being invaded by proto-Persians.
- --Tom Arnold
- Nyulnyul is essentially Bardi with no final vowels.
- --Claire
- Southeast Asian languages in general (and Cantonese, for that
matter) essentially sound like cutlery being thrown down the stairs.
- --Anonymous, via Jonathan North Washington
- Carrier is essentially French.
- --Anonymous, via Bill Poser
- Wolof is essentially English.
- --Anonymous, via Nate
- Ubykh is essentially an Abkhazian impersonation of an avalanche.
- --ubykhlives
- Esperanto
- Esperanto is essentially bad Romance with lots of German
and some Russian stirred in.
- --John Cowan
- Esperanto is essentially French spoken by a Russian.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Esperanto is essentially a crippled cross-over between Italian and Spanish.
- --Jan van Steenbergen
- Esperanto is essentially German and Latin spoken with a Yiddish accent.
- --Danny Wier
- Esperanto is essentially English, French, German, Spanish,
Italian, Russian, Latin, and Greek, invented by someone who
speaks English, French, German, Spanish, Italian, Russian,
Latin, Greek...and Polish.
- --Kapitano Eglefino
- Esperanto is essentially English/Romance/Germanic as construed into
purposeful orthographical inaccuracy by Polish/Russian.
- --Jay Bowks
- Esperanto is essentially Indo-European pidgin.
- --Roger Mills
- Esperanto is essentially Hebrew as ravaged by Modern Aryan in a
pogrom.
- --ilvi
- So it may be, but Esperanto still essentially sounds like Italian
being mugged by Polish.
- --Mia S. Soderquist
- Ido is a essentially a Jewish language spoken by an
anti-Semite.
- --Kapitano Eglefino
- Ido is essentially Esperanto, as sweet wine is essentially a bunch of
sour grapes.
- --Jay Bowks
- Ido is essentially the bastard offspring of Esperanto and Idiom Neutral.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Esperanto is essentially English, French, German, Portuguese, Swedish, Danish,
Norwegian, Italian, Spanish, Dutch, Polish, Czech, Finnish, Japanese, Mandarin,
Thai, and Russian all divided by 18.
- --Will McGree
- Esperanto is colloquial Italian.
- --Brian
- Esperanto is essentially Spanish with extra 'x's and 'k's.
- --Amos Block
- Other International Auxiliary Languages
- Novial is essentially Esperanto, reinvented by someone
who was too late to be an Idist.
- --Kapitano Eglefino
- Novial is essentially French read with a Danish pronunciation.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Re-Novial is essentially Jespersen's Novial as aged in the cask, bottled
and ready for uncorking.
- --Jay Bowks
- Novial is essentially Ido and Occidental as spoken by a Dane.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Interlingue is indisputably De Wahl's Occidental filtered by IALA.
- --Jay Bowks
- Volapuk, Esperanto, Occidental, Novial and Interlingua are essentially
butcheries of every language found in Europe.
- --Thomas Kent
- Volapuk is essentially English as gastrically processed and passed out
by a German speaker.
- --ilvi
- Latino Moderne is none other than Interlingua grammatically retrofitted.
- --Jay Bowks
- Interglossa and its descendant Glosa are essentially Basic English in Greek.
- --Nick Nicholas
- Interlingua is essentially Italian spoken by a Spaniard, or vice versa.
- --Bruce R. Gilson
- IALA Interlingua is essentially Peano's Latino sine Flexione as
influenced by unruly Latin offspring.
- --Jay Bowks
- Conversely, Peano's Interlingua (Latino sine Flexione) is essentially
IALA's Interlingua as a diamond in the rough.
- --Jay Bowks
- Solresol is essentially Octalcode before the advent of the computer and
Net English.
- --ilvi
- World Language (WL) is essentially an anthroposophical technical
draughtsman's Japanese-Californian calligraphy uttered in North American
Native sign language with a Lojbanic accent.
- --Alfred W. Tüting
- Eklektu is essentially Afrikaans, Ainu, Amharic, Arabic, Armenian, Aztec,
Bengali, Breton, Cantonese, Cherokee, Chinese, Czech, Danish, Dutch,
English, Enochian, Estonian, Finnish, French, Gamilaraay, Gashta, German,
Greek, Hawaiian, Hebrew, Hindi, Hopi, Hungarian, Indonesian, Irish,
Italian, Japanese, Jirrbal, Korean, Lakota, Latin, Latvian, Lenape, Malay,
Malagasy, Maya, Mbabaram, Navajo, Nepali, Norwegian, Passamaquoddy-
Maliseet, Polish, Portuguese, Potawatomi, Quechua, Quenya, Romanian,
Russian, Serbo-Croatian, Sindarin, Sotho, Spanish, Swahili, Swedish,
Tagalog, Thai, Tibetan, Tlingit, Turkish, Uzbek, Warungu, Warlpiri, Welsh,
Yoruba, and Zulu spoken by someone who only speaks English.
- --Herman Miller
- E-prime essentially attempts eschewing essentialism.
- --Sally Caves
- Other Artificial Languages (A-M)
- Kizidanoce is essentially 16th century Castilian, with Hangkerimian
words, Hangkerimian syntax and Latin script.
- --Chlewey Thompin
- Kizidanoce is essentially Hangkerimian as spoken with a Vulgate Bible.
- --Chlewey Thompin
- Hangkerimian is essentially Kizidanoce as spoken by that majority of
American Natives that refuse to adopt the Latin alphabet.
- --Chlewey Thompin
- Criollo is essentially Castilian with tones.
- --Chlewey Thompin
- Criollo is essentially Hangkerimian as spoken by Spanish colonists that
never cared to learn a word of Hangkerimian.
- --Chlewey Thompin
- Lojban is essentially English spoken by a computer.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Lojban is essentially predicate calculus spoken by
an Esperantist.
- --Kapitano Eglefino
- Lojban is essentially Shelta spoken by Trekkies.
- --Danny Wier
- Mungayöd is essentially German, Latin, and Greek put through a blender.
- --Dan Seriff
- Atlantean is essentially Indo-Japanese spoken when ordering a
Big Mac and fries.
- --Danny Wier
- Klingon is essentially Arabic spoken by a German with a tribble caught
in the back of his throat and a turtle on his head.
- --Peter Clark
- Klingon is essentially Arabic spoken through a set of bulky false teeth.
- --Christian Thalmann
- Klingon is essentially a Caucasian language with fewer consonants,
but still sounds Caucasian, spoken by ugly individuals that probably
never heard of the Caucasus.
- --Danny Wier
- Bajoran, Trill, Romulan, Ferengi, Vulcan and just about any language of
Star Trek is essentially what you get from a random CVC syllable
generator with standard Latin phonemes.
- --Christian Thalmann
- Aluric is essentially all the accented characters in the
Windows character set strung together.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Chleweyish is essentially Colombian Sign Language spoken by a
hearing person who never finished the lessons and threw a bunch of randomly
generated words and a few borrowings into it.
- --Chlewey Thompin
- Kalini Sapak is essentially Arabic spoken by a Swede who doesn't know
Arabic.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Madzhi is essentially bastardised Hungarian spoken by various North
American Natives.
- --Ferenc Valoczy
- Cenlatorre is essentially what you get when a Frenchman transcribes
the results of a Medieval Pope converting to Hinduism and preaching
to a crowd of monolingual Greeks.
- --Amber Adams
- My as-yet-unnamed conlang is essentially a
Quechua-Finnish pidgin spoken by Indonesians.
- --Levi Tooker
- Astou is essentially Greek and Latin spoken by Incas.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- Moten is essentially Basque with all the difficulties thrown out.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- Chasmäöcho is essentially a reader's nightmare.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- Megdevi is essentially Arabic as transmogrified by Dr. Zamenhof.
- --David Peterson
- Etábnanni /'rA(low)mn&(low)n/ is essentially unreadable.
- --Tristan Alexander Mcleay
- Kîrri is a perfectly normal Semitic language with all the
consonants stolen by Nrit.
- --Shreyas Sampat
- Etabnanni is essentially Tibetan done badly.
- --Tristan
- Gabwe is essentially creaky voice.
- --Steg Belsky
- Gabwe is essentially backwards English grammar and badly-disguised
English morphemes written in Korean by someone who doesn't know Korean.
- --Steg Belsky
- Cruzan is essentially Swiss German with an Albanian accent.
- --Christian Thalmann
- Khangaþyagon is essentially a language that sounds like Welsh to
people who don't speak Welsh.
- --Peter Bleackley
- Jarda is essentially a relexified Zireen
language with a vocabulary derived from the raccoon language Kianarthal.
- --Herman Miller
- Ithkuil is essentially bad Katanda spoken by Techians, written
in Klingon letters drawn with a ruler.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Ithkuil is essentially an unending phonetic and grammatical nightmare which
attempts to combine all the world's natlangs together into one big stew of
unlearnability and unspeakability.
- --Trebor Jung
- Mikiana is essentially English with everything but girls' names taken out.
- --Jonathan Bettencourt
- Mikiana is essentially English trying to pass itself off as a-priori.
- --Jonathan Bettencourt
- Lojban is essentially DOS with more full stops.
- --Will McGree
- Klingon is essentially Orkish with fewer vowels and more spitting.
- --Will McGree
- Ithkuil is essentially Chechen as spoken by a Welshman raised by bilingual
Chinese-speaking parents, which is recorded and then replayed backwards.
- --Michael Gerardi
- Lojban is essentially speakable first-order predicate logic with emotional decorators.
- --John Cowan
- Kash is essentially bad Indonesian spoken by a distracted librarian (Shh!).
- --Roger Mills
- Fith has essentially been adapted by the Rrodaly androids possessed of
essentially flawless memory and strong arms for stacking.
- --Sally Caves
- Keshean is essentially Dutch impersonating Sanskrit.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Meghean is essentially some reasonable language where morphology and phonology
merged into one.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Ismaîn is essentially what French would be if Latin had been Cadhinor.
- --Philip Newton
- Cuêzi is essentially the Almean moral equivalent of Greek.
- --Philip Newton
- Lojban is essentially a slight relex of TLI Loglan.
- --Philip Newton
- Mágikimnaz is essentially Khangaþyagon that tried to be
Latin, but ended up with features of Mandarin.
- --Peter Bleackley
- (B is part of A) Kelen no verbs essentially.
- --Peter Bleackley
- Mërèchi is essentially a language with decorated vowels.
- --Peter Bleackley
- Proto-Drem is essentially a language that allows Tense-Aspect-Mood-Voice
markers to run riot without proper supervision.
- --Peter Bleackley
- Star Trek is essentially a religion for secular humanists, and Klingon
is its Latin.
- --Jeffrey Henning
- Lojban is essentially Snow Crash as spoken by an Esperantist.
- --Alan Caum
- Old Albic is essentially Old European vocabulary, Germanic phonology,
Georgian grammar and Celtic word order.
- --Jörg Rhiemeier
- Other Artificial Languages (N-Z)
- Nyucar is essentially English spoken by people who make every possible
attempt not to be understood in England.
- --Chlewey Thompin
- Nadsat is essentially to Russian what Texas Spanish is to Spanish.
- --Danny Wier
- Vorlin is essentially everything you can think of,
spoken by Rick Harrison.
- --Kapitano Eglefino
- Vilani is essentially Sumerian as spoken by interstellar tax
collectors and management consultants pretending to be Aztecs.
- --Anonymous
- Yf Rgalin is essentially Lojban as it would be spoken by a Basque Klingonist
who doesn't count beyond two.
- --Mark Shoulson
- Obrenje is essentially Russian spoken while sober.
- --Christian Thalman
- Talossan is essentially English, French, Occitan, Romanian, Albanian,
Portuguese, Icelandic, and Berber as spoken by one man in his bedroom.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Veldan is essentially Greek, Latin, and Gaelic as spoken by a fictional
people who spend too much time with Elves.
- --Cian Ross
- Vranian is essentially a fusion of
Serbian, Czech, Island Tlingit and Inuktitut as spoken by a Hungarian
anarchist who wishes he was a Faroese lesbian.
- --a friend of the creator's
- Tech is essentially the IPA alphabet as viewed by a Texan.
- --Peter Clark
- Tech is essentially Arabic spoken by a Georgian.
- --Danny Wier
- Tech is essentially Arabic, Georgian and Sanskrit spoken by an Egyptian
leprechaun.
- --Danny Wier
- Rav Zarruvo is essentially Native American war chants being attempted
by a group of dyslexic Chinese with severe indigestion problems, who think
they're learning Hindi.
- --Bob Greenwade
- Northern Uatakassí is essentially Southern Uatakassí with no
diphthongs and all the vowels turned to /i/.
- --Nik Taylor
- Southern Uatakassí is essentially Northern Uatakassí with no
codas and a bunch of weird consonants.
- --Nik Taylor
- Vulgar Uatakassí is essentially Standard Uatakassí spoken by lazy
foreigners.
- --Nik Taylor
- Conversely, Standard Uatakassí is essentially Vulgar Uatakassí
spoken by snobs.
- --Nik Taylor
- Uatakassí is essentially Hawaiian spoken by Finns on crack.
- -- Amber Adams
- Uatakassí is essentially the result of an orgy involving Eskimos,
Polynesians, Bantus, and Finns, spoken by fanatically religious birds
living in a furnace.
- --Nik Taylor
- Xi is essentially politically correct Cenlatorre transliterated
into Katakana and then read by a Valley girl.
- --Amber Adams
- Nyo'fa is essentially the same, except that the aforementioned
Valley girl can't read Katakana.
- --Amber Adams
- Alternately, Nyo'fa is essentially attempting to speak Arabic
backwards while choking on a mouthful of painfully hot oatmeal.
- --Amber Adams
- Notya is essentially Japanese with all the grammar thrown out.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- O is essentially the product of an amnesiac.
- --Christophe Grandsire
- Thh:tmaa [the language of the TV show Dark Skies] grammar
is essentially a weird combination of Malagasy and predicate logic.
- --Joel Matthew Pearson
- Nrit is essentially Finnish spoken by Indians who are still coughing up
Sanskrit consonants.
- --Shreyas Sampat
- Toki Pona is essentially small.
- --Nikita Ayzikovsk
- Toki Pona is essentially English spoken by a Japanese.
- --Nikita Ayzikovsk
- Toki Pona is essentially a side effect of smoking too much weed.
- --Nikita Ayzikovsk
- Steienzh is essentially what you got if you mark
the passive present and the active participle the same.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Rokbeigalmki is essentially Hebrew and English's alien love child spoken
by half-Elven Polynesian Klingons who think it's Lojban.
- --Steg Belsky
- htwvitbveuotkvwvahfi ihv ehenvhxawlvi hinbvtbeywlv, wlveuotvhxvitkawlv,
hewlvhf-tkeuonvhihtenvt anvtv iuonvwcviuoiuohvatbveywlv.
(which translates as "Stribography is essentially simple, logical,
self-consistent and unusable.")
- --Peter Bleackley
- yxnomk atpukno ujklevt is essentially Klingon trying to look like Esperanto.
- --Robert B. Wilson
- Khangaþyagon is essentially itself.
- --Ray Brown
- Viktor Medrano (?) invented Vong or Ving or something
in order to write Zen-influenced haiku in a Hawai'ian-like loglang.
- --Hanuman Zhang
- Telendlest is essentially a variant of Tairezazh that wants to be Spanish, but
falls short.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Steienzh is essentially Classical Klaish as spoken by a Dane.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Taizh dialect is essentially Standard Tairezazh as spoken by people who think
Standard Tairezazh has too many vowels.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Yargish is essentially ergative Japanese with a lot of consonant clusters and no
labials.
- --Andreas Johansson
- Verdurian is essentially what Spanish would be if Latin had been Cadhinor.
- --Philip Newton
- Verdurian is essentially a mixture of Russian and French with a few
unique words to make it look like a separate language.
- --Philip Newton
- Kelenala is essentially Wasabi with only David Peterson as a speaker.
- --David J. Peterson
- Wasabi is essentially a bunch of words some undergraduates tried to
make resemble a language.
- --David J. Peterson
- Tolkien Languages
- Quenya is essentially Finnish as spoken by Elves.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Sindarin is essentially Welsh as spoken by Elves.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Sindarin is essentially Quenya spoken by Welsh Elves.
- --Matthew Kehrt
- Quenya is essentially Latin spoken by Elves.
- --Matthew Kehrt
- Quenya is essentially all of Tolkien's "cellar door"s lined up
one after another.
- --Benct Philip Jonsson
- Dwarvish is essentially Basque as spoken by Dwarves.
- --Thomas Leigh
- I disagree with this last statement -- Dwarvish is essentially Hebrew as
spoken by dwarves.
- --Renee
- Orkish is essentially Klingon as spoken by Orcs.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Aelya is essentially Quenya spoken by an Irishman raised in
Finland.
- --Clinton Moreland
- Cein is essentially Quenya spoken by a Frenchman
living in Wales (or a Welshman living in France).
- --Daniel Andreasson
- Quenya is essentially a bad copy of Italian.
- --Maurizio M. Gavioli
- Orkish is essentially Sumerian as spoken by angry drunks.
- --Alan Kellogg
- Elvish is essentially Finnish as spoken by a people who personally
remember the Pleistocene.
- --Alan Kellogg
- Animal Languages
- Dog is essentially a language spoken while begging for food.
- --Dan Seriff
- Cat is essentially a language spoken while begging for food, destroying
the furniture, and puking on the carpet, all while high on catnip.
- --Dan Seriff
- Cat is essentially Dog spoken while chasing a piece of string.
- --jmallett
- Cat is essentially a highly variable language privileging diphthongs, rising
inflection, sibilants, and initial labials along with very mobile facial and fecal
expressions.
- --Sally Caves
- Cat is essentially the endless repetition of the phrase "Now! Now!"
- --Xander
- Writing Systems
- The Georgian alphabet is essentially a bag of curly fries
spilled on the floor and trodden on.
- --Muke Tever
- The Armenian alphabet is essentially mangled Greek.
- --Danny Wier
- The Avestan alphabet is essentially Pahlavi with a restored sense of sanity.
- --Danny Wier
- The Tamazight alphabet is essentially geometric figures used for love
letters.
- --Danny Wier
- The Oriya script is essentially a succession of bald heads.
- --Danny Wier quoting someone else
- The Devanagari script is essentially a collection of snakes dangling from a
wire.
- --Danny Wier
- The Bengali script is essentially a collection of snakes dangling from a
wire that are better contortionists.
- --Danny Wier
- The Gujarati script is essentially a collection of snakes that fell from the
wire.
- --Danny Wier
- The Thaana (Maldivian) abjad is essentially rows of diagonal scribbles with
Arabic letters thrown in.
- --Danny Wier
- Arabic is essentially Aramaic written in a hurry.
- --Danny Wier
- Urdu writing is essentially Arabo-Persian writing, done in a hurry.
- --Danny Wier
- Cyrillic is essentially Greek written by a dyslexic Latin speaker.
- --Danny Wier
- Futhark is essentially Latin formed from carefully engineered trees.
- --Danny Wier
- Cursive Hebrew script is essentially Rashi script written by someone trying
to avoid imitating Jewish square script.
- --Danny Wier
- Hangul (Korean) is essentially Visible Speech designed to resemble Chinese.
- --Danny Wier
- Mongolian script is essentially Aramaic doing a headstand.
- --Danny Wier
- Deseret is essentially a cross between Cherokee and shorthand.
- --Clint Jackson Baker
- Traditional Chinese is essentially Simplified Chinese as written by some
people in Taiwan.
- --Jonathan Walton
- Cyrillic is essentially Greek disguised as Latin.
- --Danny Wier
- Roman script is essentially Phoenician as
written by Italians learning Euclidean geometry.
- --Daniel Baker
- Gurmukhi script is essentially Devanagari as it would appear on the computer
screens in a sci-fi movie.
- --Amber Adams
- Bengali script is essentially Devanagari as it would appear in the Indian version
of the Rocky Horror Picture Show.
- --Amber Adams
- Cambodian script is essentially Brahmi script as written by a Medieval German
calligrapher.
- --Amber Adams
- Classical Mongolian script is essentially Arabic, only written from top to bottom.
- --Carsten Becker
- The Japanese writing system is essentially amputated (or "que1 ge1 bo shao3
tui3 de") Chinese characters, invented by illiterate peasants.
- --Hanbing Feng
- Written Uighur is essentially Spaghetti with a sprinkling of Paprika.
- --Daniel Baker
- Fenair (the writing system for Eretas) is essentially badly
scrawled Nestorian masquerading as Manchu.
- --Keith Gaughan
- Greek is essentially written in the Cyrillic alphabet.
- --John Cowan
- Basque
- Basque is essentially Hexcode as used in antediluvian times.
- --ilvi
- Basque is essentially Neanderthal spoken by Spaniards.
- --Thomas Leigh
- Basque is essentially a dyslexic Cro-Magnon's lingo, discovered by the
Romans 15,000 years too late.
- --Ivan C. Amaya
- Basque is essentially English mispelled by a German.
- --Gordon Boddington
- Basque is Klingon spoken by people who don't want to be Spanish.
- --Gordon Boddington
- Basque is essentially English without the pedantic adherence to
grammatical rules.
- --Alan Kellogg
- Basque is essentially bad Gibberish.
- --John Cowan
This list is maintained by
John Cowan
<cowan@ccil.org>; if you like this, see my
home page.