[conspire] UI: not quite clear on concept: Detail Strength

Michael Paoli michael.paoli at berkeley.edu
Sat Aug 3 17:01:59 PDT 2024


So ... a couple days ago, ate some food at a casual dining place
(Maragume Udon, 1919 Shattuck Ave., Berkeley).  And, unsurprisingly they
wanted me to take their online survey.  Okay, so I obliged them ...
browser, incognito/private mode or the like, QR code ...
Select rating on quantized smiley face scale,
there's a box to add comments or whatever, and a submit button or the
like, tap the submit button - okay, it doesn't want that text box
for comments or the like left empty.  Whatever.  So, I type in some
moderate little bit of appropriate relevant text ... and as I'm doing so,
I notice a small progress bar, that initially shows almost no progress -
just a little red bit on the left, and, it indicates Detail Strength.
And as one types in more, the "Detail Strength" on the progress bar
progresses ... getting longer, and working it's way apparently from red
and short to green and long.
Yeah, I think somebody repurposed a password entry Strength indicator,
took off the bit that hides (e.g. replaces with * characters) the
individual characters as they're entered, and, well, retitled the entry
box from Password to Detail, ... thus Detail Strength and progress bar
thereof as one enters a comment or the like there.  Yeah, I don't think
they really want to optimize that field for entropy (long, complex,
random, highly unguessable ...), yet that's the feedback their progress
bar is giving on Strength.  Yeah, I think someone was unclear on the
concept ... "oops".



More information about the conspire mailing list